The Pros and Cons of Being a Tall Woman

I’m about to answer a question that I know has been eating at some of you for a while…

Just how tall is Alison?

Well, friends, I’m 6′1 (according to the doctor’s office) and it’s been.. interesting, to say the least.

I come from a tall family. My dad is 6′4 and my mom is 5′11. My older brother is 6′5. You could say that I’ve always been destined to be an Amazon.

Even though I’ve tried to make an effort to embrace my height (and try to make light of the situation), it has affected my life a lot, and honestly, it’s been a bit of a challenge at times.

Let’s go over some pros and cons, shall we?


Tall girls get noticed. There are advantages to standing out in a crowd People know me and remember me as soon as we meet (even if they don’t always remember my name, they know who I am). I’ve never been mistaken for another person maybe ever (except for my sisters – but they’re tall too). 

-I know genetics has a part in this, but it’s hard for me to put on weight no matter what I eat. Even though I’m not remarkably thin, I have long, thin arms and legs that make me look slender.

-Some people love tall girls


What is it like to be feminine? I don’t really think of myself as particularly “feminine” in the purely physiological sense. Femininity is associated with being small, delicate, petite.. and I’m none of those things. In fact, I usually feel a bit large and cumbersome most of the time. This is made even worse when I try on dresses that may as well be American Girl Doll dresses based on how well they fit me. It makes me feel like King Kong has descended on American Eagle.

Having group photos taken is the WORST. I think wedding pictures are my least favorite thing in the world. I’ve been a bridesmaid several times and nothing feels quite as bad as seeing the photographer scramble to figure out how to reframe the photo so you don’t completely ruin the composition. If you try and bend your knees to “cheat” and make yourself shorter, the camera WILL catch that and you’ll end up being the weirdo who looks like they’re popping a squat in the middle of a photoshoot

-You can never wear jumpsuits, rompers, or most one-piece swimsuits unless you want to be very, VERY uncomfortable (if ya know what I mean)

-I’ve been the target of some very thoughtless remarks. Most of them have been innocent mistakes, but it’s still rough to hear. (pro tip: women don’t like being called “huge” or “giant” no matter what the context is)

I used to try and make myself shorter by slumping when i was younger, and it’s been hard to break that bad-posture habit

-I think the worst part for me is the dating aspect. I live in Provo, Utah, which has a really strange dating culture without factoring in height. There is a dizzying amount of dating options here, which is both a good thing and a bad thing.

You already know that tall girls (as well as short men) have a major disadvantage in the dating game. And even though I feel like it’s almost a necessity for me to date someone somewhat tall-ISH (I just don’t want to absolutely tower over my significant other and be “that couple” that everyone jokes about), tall guys have virtually no reason to specifically go for tall girls. They don’t need my NBA genes, after all. So really, I’m playing at a total disadvantage here.

I dated a stocky 5′6/7 guy for a while, but the comments we were getting from total strangers were totally bizarre. Once, when we were at the grocery store together, I had sarcastically joked about being mad about something silly. The cashier piped in [to my boyfriend]: “What, did she find out you’re not going to grow any more?” It was weird and embarrassing for both of us.

All in all, I wouldn’t say that being a tall woman is a bad experience. Just like anything else, it’s absolutely what you make of it. My sisters are all tall, but they’re all confident and perfectly happy. I have another female friend who is 6 feet tall and wears high heels. I think it’s all about playing with the cards you’ve been dealt with. And despite its occasional downsides, I’m pretty much cool with it. Just don’t make me pose for another wedding picture.


The day it all fell apart

Last June, I went on my first date with Danny.  I was a different person then.  I was fickle, picky, and flaky when it came to guys.  I had gotten so used to wrinkling my nose at hopeful suitors that it became second nature. I became emotionally cold to any guy who liked me that didn’t fit the bill of my perfect man.

I wasn’t immediately in love with Danny.  I thought he was cute, but I wasn’t gaga for him by any means.  It was obvious that he liked me, though, and I gave it a chance.

I had no idea that I was going to fall more deeply in love with him than I’d ever felt before about any other living being.  Within months, he became my everything.  As I shared my life with him and his life with mine, we grew closer.

I went to Arizona with him for Christmas, and I grew to love Danny even more as I fell in love with his family.  The “M” word began to be mentioned.  He actually admitted that he wanted to marry me as soon as possible.  He would be moving to Oregon in September, and I committed to moving there with him as his wife. Even though I was initially unsure, I was ecstatic.

But there was something in our way that we couldn’t surmount, and that is that horrible thing called doubt.  Doubt crept into our relationship in January.  As we both seriously prayed to our Heavenly Father about whether it was right, problems started to surface.

The ear-to-ear grin that Danny got every time he saw me suddenly was replaced by a somewhat-forced smile.  I noticed, but I refused to attribute that to our own relationship, instead thinking that he must have had a hard day.  As I tried to pray about it, I was just feeling… nothing. I felt like I wasn’t getting any sort of answer.

Suddenly the word doubt began to emerge in some of his conversations with me.  “I have doubts about whether this will work out…” He was worried that his busy schedule as a masters student wasn’t allowing enough time to truly make me happy. I would always try to ease those doubts, telling him that I was fine and that any problems we had could be worked out.  But none of my encouragement seemed to help. I could see the uneasiness on his face between moments of happiness.

I was feeling apprehensive, too, but I am a professional at burying any unwanted feelings.  I wanted it to work out.  I wanted to move to Oregon with him.  I wanted to spend forever with this wonderful man.  It was a mind-over-matter situation.

As I shared with him my desire to be married one night, all I got for a response was that he wasn’t feeling good enough about it.  I cried all night.

The next week, I was feeling like I needed some serious answers.  As I was preparing for a Sunday School lesson, I watched a video about personal revelation.  It explained that if you ask in faith, you’ll know exactly what you were supposed to do.  Suddenly, I knew I needed to pray seriously about this.

I got down on my knees and told my Heavenly Father that I wanted to marry Danny.  I asked to know whether it was right.  But I got a very peculiar feeling.  It was a feeling of unease.

I rephrased my question.  I asked Heavenly Father if I should break up with him.  I suddenly felt a calmness, as an assurance that I was going to be okay.  Heavenly Father loves me and he wanted me to happy.

I felt like I had gotten my answer.  It wasn’t right.  Tears started to stream down my face.  I began to justify what I had felt–maybe it was because Danny didn’t want to marry me right now.  Maybe it was a timing thing, and in a few weeks, my answer would be a resounding yes.  I hesitated on breaking it off with Danny, because I didn’t know the why. In my mind, it was still going to work, and I was going to ensure that.

But the unease I felt only continued.  Things started to get a little weird.  When people asked me about Oregon, I would get a knot in my stomach.  I felt rushed to get married.  I had a hard time even picturing us engaged anymore.  But the relationship continued, and we did the same things we always did.

Then yesterday happened.  My cousin became engaged and their date was set in September–a month after Danny and I had set our tentative wedding date in August.  I went over to his apartment and explained how this was making me feel antsy about getting engaged, too.

He had a look on his face–a look I will never forget.  It was devastating.  He looked as though he was going to cry.

“We need to go somewhere alone to pray about whether we should get married.”

I knew at that moment what was about to happen. This was the end.  I already knew the answer to the question, because I had felt it before, and I felt it as soon as he had said that.

It was the most awkward car ride in the world as we drove on campus to an empty classroom to pray.  Neither of us was saying anything, and there was an air of mourning in the car.  He still had that harrowing expression, but this time with a blank stare. I felt a million miles away from him.

When we got to the empty classroom, we sat down on the floor.  I felt tears coming.

“I need to admit something to you,” he said quietly. “The other day, when I prayed about whether we were right for each other… I felt like we weren’t. But,” he added, “I felt like we were going to be okay.”

I lost it at that point.  I finally admitted what I had been feeling when I prayed. “I felt the exact same way.”

There was nothing more to be said at that point–we both knew it was the end.  We cried in each other’s arms for several hours, mourning the loss of an amazing relationship.

As we said our goodbyes, we told each other we still loved each other. Nothing was going to change that.  We assured each other that this wasn’t then end of our friendship, only the relationship.  But the pain was still terrible. We ended it with a kiss.
I don’t know why the Lord didn’t feel like we were compatible.  It is a reality that hurts me to my innermost core when I think about it.  I don’t know why the Lord works in the way that he does.  But I am reminded of the promise that we both had–that we will be okay. This was the hardest experience of my life thus far, but I know that somewhere down the road the pain will go away.  The feeling of wanting to curl up and die will one day ebb, and I can be happy again.  I am going to need to learn how to live without him, and that will be the hardest part.  But somewhere, down the line, I will find my happiness again.